Matthew Harris (glowing_fish ) wrote in doctorwho ,

Things that didn't make sense about The Time of the Doctor:

I hope that no one is spoiled by that title! Someone might be surprised to find out that an episode of Doctor Who has its inconsistencies! But more seriously, here are some things that were so confusing that they sunk the story for me:



I guess my biggest disappointment was that the Battle of Trenzalore was depicted as an epic confrontation, with gigantic armies dying in a pitched battle: and instead what we see is the Doctor with a few villagers, holding pitchforks, and holding off an army of Daleks? For several hundred years.

We were also told that on Trenzalore, no one can lie or fail to speak (I believe). And yet the Doctor is being asked the question for several hundred years, and he manages to "fail to speak".

In The Name of the Doctor, we see the Doctor's grave, and a wrecked and growing TARDIS on Trenzalore. Neither of these seem to be possible, since the Doctor flies off, in the TARDIS, at the end of the episode.

River Song's grave was on Trenzalore, which requires some explaining.

The Silence, who were built up as a gigantic, mysterious threat, were dismissed as simply a renegade order of the Papal Mainframe.

The TARDIS exploding, which caused the Cracks in Time, weren't really explained.

The entire last story of the Doctor giving his sonic screwdriver to River before the Library seems to not be resolved, although it was hinted at in some mini-episodes.

I am pretty forgiving of continuity lapses if they don't ruin the story. Timey-Wimeyness is part of the deal. But I feel that a lot of stuff was done contrary to narrative logic: mostly that was built up as a gigantic battle where secrets would be revealed were just dismissed out of hand. "The scariest villains with a mysterious agenda that had the key to what was going on? Oh, just some unimportant, minor renegades"

Overall, I am a bit disappointed. I get the feeling that this was rushed through and that most of the effort was put into the 50th anniversary (which I liked).

Tags: reviews and reactions
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 30 comments